The High Court in London ruled that BP did not have the right to pass this debt on to NBAD, noting that the contract between BP and Samir stipulated that there could be no assignment of obligations or rights without reasonable consent
and that SAMIRS's consent had not been obtained.
David Potter, prosecuting, said she was extremely drunk and by the time she saw Caunce she was incapable of forming reasonable consent
Only recently has the law recognized that a person needs information about a proposed procedure to give reasonable consent
to that procedure.
After making this "conceptual" argument, the author (with unintended irony) explains that it provides little help for those who would defend most of the violations adversary practices permit, since those practices typically permit viol ations in circumstances that would not warrant reasonable consent
(although there are exceptions which the author describes).
Some Reflections Upon Marriage (1700) rejects the marriage/social contract homology to argue that reasonable consent
is not the ground of wifely obedience to husbands.